Saturday, August 9, 2025

TODAY'S AMERICAN CATHOLIC

 

Matthew Fox speaks to the Association of Pittsburgh Priests, August 6, 2025

This past Wednesday, theologian and Episcopal priest Matthew Fox gave an online presentation entitled “Père Chenu: Father of Liberation Theology, Creation Spirituality, and Much of Vatican II” for the Association of Pittsburgh Priests. Over 250 participants joined the call to listen to Fox’s memories, reflections, and insights into the life of the Dominican theologian, whose work continues to impact the church today.


 
Fox knows his subject well, having studied with him in the late 1960s at the Institut catholique de Paris. It was Thomas Merton who encouraged Fox to pursue his doctorate at the Institut—a fitting bit of soul-friendship that is still bearing fruit through Fox’s many writings and public initiatives.
 
From Chenu, Fox learned that there were two divergent strands of Christian spirituality: one beginning with the Fall and leading to redemption, and the other beginning with Creation. Biblically speaking, Fox noted, the latter is the “older source.” He described this discovery as “a complete revelation.”
 
Fox lauded the book Chenu published in 1968, Nature, Man, and Society in the Twelfth Century, as “an absolute classic.” He drew attention to how nature—“another word for creation”—comes first in the title, and explained Chenu’s view that the renaissance of the twelfth century was cultivated by workers from the “bottom up” as opposed to the “top-down” renaissance of the fifteenth century. In line with this insight, Fox characterized Chenu’s view of history as being not about “individuals” but “the people” as a whole.
 
Chenu was condemned several times by the church hierarchy, including Pope Pius XII and the head of the Dominican order. His 1937 publication, Une école de théologie: Le Saulchoir, was placed on the Vatican’s Index of Forbidden Books in 1942. Ironically, the book is a veritable “menu” of topics that would be explored, elaborated, and codified during the Second Vatican Council, Fox explained.
 
Chenu’s reputation was rehabilitated in 1962 when an African bishop from Madagascar invited him to be his theological advisor at the council. Fox noted how a “trinity” of Chenu’s ideas—“reading the signs of the times,” “continuous creation,” and “continuous incarnation”—were fundamental to the theology of the council and the language of Gaudium et Spes in particular.
 
Fox went on to share some of his favorite quotes from Chenu’s corpus: “Faithful questioning is the most acute expression of the life of the Spirit”; “The Holy Spirit cannot be a prisoner of rationality”; “Tradition is not an inventory of propositions bundled in a book of dogmas”; “The history of Spirit is the history of nature.”
 
Toward the end of his life, Chenu “prayed almost exclusively to the Holy Spirit,” Fox said. He recalled one of his teacher’s favorite credos: “There is no fear of change, because change is in the hands of the Holy Spirit.” Following the notion that the Spirit “makes all things new,” his prayer life lent him an element of youthful flexibility. “The youngest man I ever met in my life was 76 years old,” Fox said. “He had not an ounce of bitterness for all the struggle he’d been through.”
 
Gustavo Gutiérrez called Chenu the father of liberation theology; Yves Congar, his student, received his ecumenism from him and helped develop it in conciliar documents such as Unitatis Redintegratio; and Fox himself credits him with naming and sparking the movement that was to become creation spirituality. That one of Fox’s students was a primary drafter of Laudato Si’ shows how Chenu’s teachings now have generational import, redounding to a twenty-first-century eco-theology where “the human person is entirely one with the cosmos.” Fox sees this a signal moment to keep building on the legacy of his mentor: “You don’t freeze a prophetic movement. You take its energy and you keep moving, and looking for the next invitation to the prophetic.”

Michael Centore
Editor, Today's American Catholic

No comments:

Post a Comment